John D. Chitty
“The Misadventures of Captain Headknowledge” -- Rescuing victims of villainous theology since 2006. "I'm from Geneva, and I'm here to help!"
Church History Blogs
Presbyterian & Reformed
- 1517
- abeance [uh-bey-uhns] old French: expectation, longing
- Ancient-Reformed Worship
- Aquila Report
- Beggars All
- But In These Last Days
- Christian Nurture
- Confessional Presbyterian Journal
- DFW Reformed
- Feeding On Christ
- Grantian Florilegium
- Green Baggins
- Heidelblog
- Historia Salutis
- Housewife Theologian
- Humble Theology
- In Principio…Deus
- J. Gresham Machen Blog
- jgmachen.org
- Ligonier Ministries Blog
- Meet the Puritans
- Mid Cities Presbyterian Church Library
- Old Life Theological Society
- Pastor Mathis
- Place for Truth
- Postcards from Palookaville
- Presbyterian Curmudgeon
- Rachel Green Miller
- Reepicheep Blog
- Reflections Blog
- Reformation Heritage Books Blog
- Reformation Society Blog
- Reformation21 Blog
- Reformed Bibliophile
- Reformed Literature
- Reformed Reader
- The Christian Curmudgeon
- The Gordian Knot
- The Gospel-Marinated Life
- The Riddleblog
- The Wittenberg Door
- The World's Ruined Blog
- This Day in Presbyterian History
- Thoughts of Francis Turretin
- Underdog Theology
- Valiant for Truth
Top Five Posts
Visual Misadventures
Misadventurous Tweets
- RT @Tabletalk: The expansive English Bible selection we enjoy today is the end product of a long and winding history, a history marked by s… 23 hours ago
- If you liked the bumper music on the Nov 13 @presbycast, I hope you’ll enjoy my song of the same theme.… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 month ago
- RT @mc_opc: The Westminster Assembly and the Reformation of Preaching, 1643-1653 | Dr. Chad Van Dixhoorn | DFW Ref Con 2019 https://t.co/6S… 1 month ago
Goodreads
Mid-Cities Presbyterian Church (OPC) Sermon Podcast
- Today You Will Be with Me in Paradise October 28, 2018Mr. Mossotti - Luke 23:39-43
- Saintly Greetings and Benedictions October 21, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:21-23
- The God Who Provides October 14, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:19-20
- Partners in Trouble October 7, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:14-18
- Content in All Things through the Strength of Christ September 30, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:10-13
Categories
- Anti-Intellectualism (7)
- Atheism (1)
- Biblical Archaeology (1)
- Biblical Commentary (104)
- Blog Features (23)
- Books (121)
- Calvinism (1)
- Captain Headknowledge: The Early Years (39)
- Catechism (69)
- Cessationism (1)
- Christmas (1)
- Church History (250)
- Anabaptism (13)
- Heretics (2)
- Arius (1)
- Docetism (1)
- Gnosticism (1)
- John Calvin (26)
- Jonathan Edwards (1)
- Martin Luther (41)
- Protestant Reformation (6)
- Restorationism (1)
- Rev. John Brown of Haddington (21)
- Thinking About Church History (75)
- Trueman, Carl (1)
- Clary, Glen (1)
- Creeds (4)
- Nicene Creed (1)
- Culture and Politics (48)
- Bowe Bergdahl (1)
- Constantinism (1)
- Feminism (1)
- Homosexuality (5)
- Marvel Comics (1)
- Star Wars (2)
- Two Kingdoms (8)
- Easter (1)
- Eastern Orthodoxy (4)
- Hank Hanegraaff (1)
- humor (23)
- Islam (5)
- J. Gresham Machen (1)
- Live Blogging (2)
- Master, Jonathan (2)
- Michael Card (1)
- Miracles (1)
- N.T. Wright (1)
- Office Hours (1)
- OPC, Galatians, Grace, Faith, Justification, Repentance, Presbyterian, Preaching, Sermon (1)
- Orthodox Presbyterian Church (13)
- Personal (72)
- Podcast (14)
- Christ the Center (4)
- East of Eden (1)
- Janet Mefferd (2)
- Protestantism (337)
- Baptist (68)
- Evangelicalism (151)
- Fundamentalism (48)
- J. Frank Norris (10)
- KJVOx (2)
- Peter Ruckman (3)
- Reformed Theology (224)
- Canons of Dort (1)
- Doctrines of Grace (48)
- Effectual Call (5)
- Foreknowledge (1)
- Particular Redemption (4)
- Perseverance of the Saints (3)
- Radical Corruption (1)
- Total Depravity (7)
- Presbyterian (86)
- Toward a Modern Reformation (60)
- Westminster Confession of Faith (12)
- Westminster Theological Seminary (16)
- Radio (40)
- Etc. (1)
- Grace To You (2)
- Issues (1)
- Redeemer Broadcasting (1)
- White Horse Inn (17)
- Reformed (1)
- Reliability of the Bible (77)
- King James Version (34)
- Textual Criticism (24)
- Roman Catholicism (3)
- Saluting Real Captains Headknowledge (71)
- Science (6)
- Theological Issues (380)
- Apologetics (17)
- Campbellism (1)
- Christocentricity (69)
- Christology (9)
- Complementarianism (4)
- Creationism (2)
- Ecumenism (2)
- Eschatology (23)
- Harold Camping (10)
- Evangelism (7)
- Federal Vision (1)
- Glory of God (1)
- Gospel (39)
- Hermeneutics (18)
- Hyper-Calvinism (1)
- Inerrancy (11)
- Inspiration (18)
- Justification (14)
- Modernist Liberalism (6)
- Moral Law (17)
- The Ten Commandments (11)
- Original Sin (1)
- Patriarchalism (1)
- Postmodern Liberalism (21)
- Rob Bell (13)
- Practical Application (41)
- Suffering (2)
- Universalism (6)
- Word of Faith Movement (6)
- Worship (140)
- Music for Mind and Heart (89)
- Preaching (34)
- Sermon Notes (6)
- Regulative Principle (4)
- Sacramentology (18)
- Trinity Hymnal (9)
- Uncategorized (79)
- Video (64)
- Watcman Fellowship (2)
- William Dennison (2)
The Hermeneutics of Insider Syncretism
On this week’s episode of the Christ the Center podcast (#263, “Insider Movements“), Dr. David Garner is interviewed about his recent article in Themelios, “High Stakes: Insider Movement Hermeneutics and the Gospel,” analyzing the hermeneutics underlying the Insider Movement, a sociological and anthropological approach to contextualizing evangelism without calling on people whose identities are tied to other world religions like Judaism, Islam and Hinduism to disassociate themselves from those religious, cultural and family ties, but to work inside them and transform their approach to those religions in light of the teachings of Jesus. While it is noble to attempt to find a way to minimize the risk of loss or danger a Jew, Muslim or Hindu (for example) may face upon becoming a Christian, it is unfaithful to the Jesus they claim to follow if they would settle for living to distort their new-found faith with the teachings and practices of the religion with which they have previously been associated. Living to syncretize Christianity with non-Christian world religions is not a faith worth living for or dying for.
This movement is clearly in contradiction with the teachings of Jesus to those who would follow him. Jesus carried his cross and died on it for those who believe, and he calls on believers to take up their cross, follow him, and be willing to live publicly for him and, if need be, accept rejection by leaders of other religions, communities and families, even if such rejection includes dying for him.
I know it’s easy for me to say, and to criticize those who would find a way around it, but I too have a cross of self-denial to carry if I am to follow Jesus. I must kill my own sin (a struggle which involves suffering and risk of social rejection on my part), and publicly acknowledge Jesus as my Lord and Savior and associate myself formally with his people, the Church (Hebrews 10:25), serving him with my time, talent and treasure–loving, forgiving and giving to my brothers until it hurts. Should the time come that the culture or community in which I live demands that I deny my Lord Jesus Christ, I am called upon to defy such a demand and willingly suffer the consequences in reliance upon the grace and goodness of God, knowing that if such is happening to me, it is no more than what he sacrificed for me.
One of the interesting things about this movement which Dr. Garner points out in the article and the interview is that the intellectual source of such innovation in world missions comes from the same root as the church growth movement–Donald McGavran (d. 1990) and his School of Intercultural Studies at Fuller Theological Seminary (formerly the famous School of World Mission).
While McGavran’s efforts in his time were more theologically conservative and a reaction against liberal missionary trends, a student of his named C. Peter Wagner built on McGavran’s principles and create the church growth movement which has brought us such phenomena as seeker-sensitive worship and the modern megachurch. Incidentally, he is also the one who coined the phrase New Apostolic Reformation for the worldwide sweep of Charismatic and Word of Faith theology with a special emphasis on the restoration of the apostolic office, which movement in America has recently frightened the political Left because so many who would fall under this umbrella have modified the theonomist views of R. J. Rushdoony (for more on that, see this) and declared that they would “take dominion” over every sphere of influence in America.
Syncretism in the name of saving one’s life is no way to spread Christianity. A new generation around the world must hear the age-old truism: “The blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church” [paraphrasing Tertullian, Apology chapter 50].
Share this:
Like this:
Related