What’s the difference between the Jesus People of the 1970’s and the Postmodern Liberals of the Twenty-First Century?
John D. Chitty
“The Misadventures of Captain Headknowledge” -- Rescuing victims of villainous theology since 2006. "I'm from Geneva, and I'm here to help!"
Church History Blogs
Presbyterian & Reformed
- 1517
- abeance [uh-bey-uhns] old French: expectation, longing
- Ancient-Reformed Worship
- Aquila Report
- Beggars All
- But In These Last Days
- Christian Nurture
- Confessional Presbyterian Journal
- DFW Reformed
- Feeding On Christ
- Grantian Florilegium
- Green Baggins
- Heidelblog
- Historia Salutis
- Housewife Theologian
- Humble Theology
- In Principio…Deus
- J. Gresham Machen Blog
- jgmachen.org
- Ligonier Ministries Blog
- Meet the Puritans
- Mid Cities Presbyterian Church Library
- Old Life Theological Society
- Pastor Mathis
- Place for Truth
- Postcards from Palookaville
- Presbyterian Curmudgeon
- Rachel Green Miller
- Reepicheep Blog
- Reflections Blog
- Reformation Heritage Books Blog
- Reformation Society Blog
- Reformation21 Blog
- Reformed Bibliophile
- Reformed Literature
- Reformed Reader
- The Christian Curmudgeon
- The Gordian Knot
- The Gospel-Marinated Life
- The Riddleblog
- The Wittenberg Door
- The World's Ruined Blog
- This Day in Presbyterian History
- Thoughts of Francis Turretin
- Underdog Theology
- Valiant for Truth
Top Five Posts
Visual Misadventures
Misadventurous Tweets
- Here’s a timely one: “Fail with honor rather than succeed by fraud.”~#StarWars: The Clone Wars, season 1, episode 12. 10 hours ago
- Ideologically-motivated violent extremists with objections to the exercise of governmental authority and the presid… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 13 hours ago
- RT @JimGaffigan: Nothing says “democracy” like protecting a narcissistic tyrant because if you don’t, his supporters will break in your hou… 13 hours ago
Goodreads
Mid-Cities Presbyterian Church (OPC) Sermon Podcast
- Today You Will Be with Me in Paradise October 28, 2018Mr. Mossotti - Luke 23:39-43
- Saintly Greetings and Benedictions October 21, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:21-23
- The God Who Provides October 14, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:19-20
- Partners in Trouble October 7, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:14-18
- Content in All Things through the Strength of Christ September 30, 2018Rev. Troutman - Philippians 4:10-13
Categories
- Anti-Intellectualism (7)
- Atheism (1)
- Biblical Archaeology (1)
- Biblical Commentary (104)
- Blog Features (23)
- Books (121)
- Calvinism (1)
- Captain Headknowledge: The Early Years (39)
- Catechism (69)
- Cessationism (1)
- Christmas (1)
- Church History (250)
- Anabaptism (13)
- Heretics (2)
- Arius (1)
- Docetism (1)
- Gnosticism (1)
- John Calvin (26)
- Jonathan Edwards (1)
- Martin Luther (41)
- Protestant Reformation (6)
- Restorationism (1)
- Rev. John Brown of Haddington (21)
- Thinking About Church History (75)
- Trueman, Carl (1)
- Clary, Glen (1)
- Creeds (4)
- Nicene Creed (1)
- Culture and Politics (48)
- Bowe Bergdahl (1)
- Constantinism (1)
- Feminism (1)
- Homosexuality (5)
- Marvel Comics (1)
- Star Wars (2)
- Two Kingdoms (8)
- Easter (1)
- Eastern Orthodoxy (4)
- Hank Hanegraaff (1)
- humor (23)
- Islam (5)
- J. Gresham Machen (1)
- Live Blogging (2)
- Master, Jonathan (2)
- Michael Card (1)
- Miracles (1)
- N.T. Wright (1)
- Office Hours (1)
- OPC, Galatians, Grace, Faith, Justification, Repentance, Presbyterian, Preaching, Sermon (1)
- Orthodox Presbyterian Church (13)
- Personal (72)
- Podcast (14)
- Christ the Center (4)
- East of Eden (1)
- Janet Mefferd (2)
- Protestantism (337)
- Baptist (68)
- Evangelicalism (151)
- Fundamentalism (48)
- J. Frank Norris (10)
- KJVOx (2)
- Peter Ruckman (3)
- Reformed Theology (224)
- Canons of Dort (1)
- Doctrines of Grace (48)
- Effectual Call (5)
- Foreknowledge (1)
- Particular Redemption (4)
- Perseverance of the Saints (3)
- Radical Corruption (1)
- Total Depravity (7)
- Presbyterian (86)
- Toward a Modern Reformation (60)
- Westminster Confession of Faith (12)
- Westminster Theological Seminary (16)
- Radio (40)
- Etc. (1)
- Grace To You (2)
- Issues (1)
- Redeemer Broadcasting (1)
- White Horse Inn (17)
- Reformed (1)
- Reliability of the Bible (77)
- King James Version (34)
- Textual Criticism (24)
- Roman Catholicism (3)
- Saluting Real Captains Headknowledge (71)
- Science (6)
- Theological Issues (380)
- Apologetics (17)
- Campbellism (1)
- Christocentricity (69)
- Christology (9)
- Complementarianism (4)
- Creationism (2)
- Ecumenism (2)
- Eschatology (23)
- Harold Camping (10)
- Evangelism (7)
- Federal Vision (1)
- Glory of God (1)
- Gospel (39)
- Hermeneutics (18)
- Hyper-Calvinism (1)
- Inerrancy (11)
- Inspiration (18)
- Justification (14)
- Modernist Liberalism (6)
- Moral Law (17)
- The Ten Commandments (11)
- Original Sin (1)
- Patriarchalism (1)
- Postmodern Liberalism (21)
- Rob Bell (13)
- Practical Application (41)
- Suffering (2)
- Universalism (6)
- Word of Faith Movement (6)
- Worship (140)
- Music for Mind and Heart (89)
- Preaching (34)
- Sermon Notes (6)
- Regulative Principle (4)
- Sacramentology (18)
- Trinity Hymnal (9)
- Uncategorized (79)
- Video (64)
- Watcman Fellowship (2)
- William Dennison (2)
I think the difference is the starting point. Jesus People at one time were actually leftist hippies. However, I think guys like Bell and some of the others like Pagitt etc…prove that they never were actually evangelicals. They played one on T.V. but were not in fact evangelical.
You may be right.
I think the Jesus movement started out with seed of something good – but quickly deteriorated because of the trait it held in common with Post-moderns — that being that they were too quick to rationalize rebellion — their “counter-culture” downgraded (good term, huh ) to contra-orthodoxy.
I’ll buy that. I’m sure there are many similarities even among this one chief difference: the former were moving toward a non-legalistic form of basically conservative theology, while the latter is moving away from it.
The Jesus movement (I was there) was a quasi-Christian response to the anti-war movement rebellionism of the day. It was far from pure though there were many sincere participants pursuing God and struggling for a better understanding of Christian-ness from which a few notable leaders arose. Most everyone was confused as to what was real. Mainstream elites had started to blitz the communication media with godless philosophy and the youth of the Christian society incorporated what little doctinal foundation they had with the rebellious energy generated by uninformed opposition to the Vietnam war. What I am trying to say in a few words is that the movement was broad, stretching just outside the confines of orthodoxy on the liberal side (part of the aim was to be unorthodox). If one looked right down the center of it, I believe a sincere but very shallow faith was visible. Today, sophistication, rather than rebellion, is the motif. A seductive rationalism appeals to the scientifically driven, but undeveloped minds (philosophically speaking) of this generation. Some will emerge with a faith because “seeking, they will find”. Others will grow tired of the lack of depth and move on to “more meaningful” philosophies since thier aim really wasn’t to re-unite with the Creator anyway. And that is the similarity between the two.
One note, also — the infamous cult “Children of God” (David Brandt Berg) had its roots in the Jesus movement. Clearly the movement was and is an enigma.
I know they didn’t all hit the nail on the head, but was not Jews for Jesus also a product of the Jesus movement in some way? When Larry Norman died, I read that one of the co-founders was led to faith in Christ by him. And was not the contemporary Christian music industry an outgrowth of their “unorthodox" rebellion against the church’s rejection of rock music? That’s generally an evangelical product of it, unintended consequence though it was.
Why should the devil have all the good music?
They say to cut my hair
They’re driving me insane
I grew it out long
to make room for my brain!